This table excludes nothing and includes everything -- all nominations for all awards and polls for all types of nominees.

Artist Michael Whelan has won more awards of all types than anyone else. Connie Willis leads for works of short fiction having overtaken Ursula K. Le Guin, who earlier overtook Harlan Ellison.

Robert Silverberg has the most 'nominations'--though keep in mind these figures include all rankings on the Locus and other reader polls.

John Barnes currently has the sad distinction of being nominated most without ever having won. Lisa Goldstein, who held this title for many years, won both a Sidewise Award and a Mythopoeic Award in 2012.

Updated October 2019: The leads of Whelan, Willis, Silverberg, and Barnes have not changed in five years.

83	Michael Whelan
78	Gardner Dozois (7)
66	Ursula K. Le Guin (50)
58	Neil Gaiman (43)
57	Harlan Ellison (41)
56	Connie Willis (53)
50	Ellen Datlow
48	David Langford (2)
43	George R. R. Martin (36)
42	Bob Eggleton
41	Mike Resnick (39)
40	Stephen King (28), Robert J. Sawyer (39)
39	no award (26)
38	Robert Silverberg (28)
36	Greg Egan (35)
35	Donato Giancola, Joe Haldeman (33), Dan Simmons (34)
33	Charles N. Brown, Stephen Jones (1)
32	Orson Scott Card (30)
30	Ted Chiang (27), Lucius Shepard (25)
29	Isaac Asimov (22), Tansy Rayner Roberts (13)

267	Robert Silverberg (183) [38]
224	Ellen Datlow [50]
214	Ursula K. Le Guin (171) [66]
210	Gardner Dozois (50) [78]
180	Michael Swanwick (168) [19]
179	Michael Whelan [83]
173	Stephen King (138) [40]
170	Bob Eggleton [42]
167	Greg Egan (158) [36]
165	Lucius Shepard (147) [30], Connie Willis (157) [56]
162	Mike Resnick (140) [41]
160	Gene Wolfe (149) [26]
152	George R. R. Martin (122) [43]
146	David G. Hartwell [20], Harlan Ellison (101) [57]
145	Kim Stanley Robinson (138) [23]
144	Stephen Jones (1) [33]
142	Nancy Kress (134) [22]
141	Jonathan Strahan (1) [18]
140	Stephen Baxter (132) [21]
133	Robert Reed (129) [7]
129	Neil Gaiman (86) [58]
128	Frederik Pohl (90) [28]
126	Orson Scott Card (113) [32]
123	Poul Anderson (108) [26]
122	Ian McDonald (117) [18]
119	Michael Bishop (105) [14]
118	Terri Windling (2) [12]
117	Bruce Sterling (106) [11]
115	Joe Haldeman (105) [35], James Patrick Kelly (108) [10]
112	Don Maitz [17]
109	Robert J. Sawyer (101) [40], Jim Burns (1) [24]
108	Isaac Asimov (61) [29], Kristine Kathryn Rusch (70) [25], Gregory Benford (91) [11]
104	Larry Niven (89) [23]
96	Donato Giancola [35]
95	David Langford (10) [48], Martin H. Greenberg [7], Jeff VanderMeer (36) [10]
93	Vincent Di Fate [11], Tanith Lee (76) [6], Charles Stross (91) [11]
92	Lois McMaster Bujold (90) [25]
91	Tansy Rayner Roberts (38) [29], Kelly Link (44) [18], John Varley (84) [27]
90	Fritz Leiber (69) [27]

40	John Barnes (39)
35	R. Garcia y Robertson (34)
29	Paul Park (29)
28	Scott Edelman (12)
27	Ron Walotsky
25	Charles Coleman Finlay (15)
24	Liz Williams (22), Darrell K. Sweet, James Van Pelt (24), L. Timmel Duchamp (20)
23	Alexander Jablokov (22), William Barton (23)
22	John C. Wright (21)
21	Hilbert Schenck (20), Stephen Youll
20	Charles L. Harness (18)
19	Benjamin Rosenbaum (18), Rebecca Ore (18)
18	Justina Robson (17)
17	Carolyn Ives Gilman (17)
16	Steven H Silver
15	Sharyn November, Alan Baxter (13), Rudyard Kipling (15), Ben Baldwin
14	Evelyn C. Leeper, Guy H. Lillian III, A. A. Attanasio (13), Ian Whates (4), Kevin J. Maroney, Michael P. Kube-McDowell (14), Ben Peek (11)

229	Robert Silverberg [38]
174	Ellen Datlow [50]
161	Michael Swanwick [19]
148	Ursula K. Le Guin [66]
135	Lucius Shepard [30]
134	Gene Wolfe [26]
133	Stephen King [40]
132	Gardner Dozois [78]
131	Greg Egan [36]
128	Bob Eggleton [42]
126	Robert Reed [7], David G. Hartwell [20]
123	Jonathan Strahan [18]
122	Kim Stanley Robinson [23]
121	Mike Resnick [41]
120	Nancy Kress [22]
119	Stephen Baxter [21]
111	Stephen Jones [33]
109	George R. R. Martin [43], Connie Willis [56]
106	Bruce Sterling [11], Terri Windling [12]
105	Michael Bishop [14], James Patrick Kelly [10]
104	Ian McDonald [18]
100	Frederik Pohl [28]
97	Poul Anderson [26], Gregory Benford [11]
96	Michael Whelan [83]
95	Don Maitz [17]
94	Orson Scott Card [32]
89	Harlan Ellison [57]
88	Martin H. Greenberg [7]
87	Tanith Lee [6]
85	Jim Burns [24], Jeff VanderMeer [10]
83	Kristine Kathryn Rusch [25]
82	Charles Stross [11], Vincent Di Fate [11]
81	Paul J. McAuley [6], Larry Niven [23]
80	Joe Haldeman [35]
79	Isaac Asimov [29]
78	Howard Waldrop [4]
77	Alastair Reynolds [5]