(7 nominations; 1 win)
 
“Nadelman's God”   (Dark Gods)
  novella  winner
 
The Ceremonies   (Viking)
  novel  nomination
 
  for Twilight Zone
  special award, professional  nomination
 
  for Twilight Zone
  special award, professional  nomination
 
“Children of the Kingdom ”   (Dark Forces)
  short fiction  nomination
 
“Petey ”   (Shadows 2)
  short story  nomination
 
“The Events at Poroth Farm ”   (The Year's Best Horror Stories, No. 3; The Year's Best Horror Stories: Series II)
  short fiction  nomination
 
 
 
British Fantasy Awards  
for fantasy works published in the UK, voted by British Fantasy Society members, juried since 2012 
 
 (1 nomination; 1 win)
 
The Ceremonies   (Viking)
  August Derleth Award (novel)  winner
 
 
 
 
Locus Awards  
for SF/F/H works, polled by readers of Locus Magazine 
 
 (2 nominations)
 
The Ceremonies   (Viking)
  fantasy novel  25th place
 
The Ceremonies   (Viking)
  first novel  8th place
 
 
 
 
Balrog Awards  
for fantasy works, presented an annual FoolsCon in Kansas City 
 
 (2 nominations)
 
  
professional achievement  nomination
 
“Children of the Kingdom ”   (Dark Forces)
  short fiction  nomination